Opinions on Apprenticing

CCbonsai

I was wondering your opinions/comments on apprenticing. I heard both sides of the topic and just wanted to hear any other info. regarding apprenticing in Japan.
THanks
RJ

Advertisement

Bonsainut

CC,
Are you thinking of following in the footsteps of Shaner, Manning, Makashima, and Manakativipart?
If so get you hands on all the back issues of golden State magazine for a good look at daily activities. Especially 1989 thru 94 or so.
A huge commitment but a cool future occupation.

__________________
Keep growing,---'Nut



Lethal Use of Farce

Earl

I'm certainly no expert but I can't help but think it would be terrific if you are planning to dedicate your life to bonsai. I can't think of anything better than doing extensive training under the tutelage of a great master. In fact, I suppose even if it remains a hobby and you have the means to take the time, it would still be great.

Is the negative along the lines of being steeped in one school of thought or one philosophy? As long as that is understood I don't see a problem.

In my former career (psychotherapy) I chose to do my intensive training in a Freudian program. I disagreed with 75% of Freud's thinking and now 90% but the training was invaluable. It taught me a disciplined way of thinking that few other schools of psychology teach. It also taught me classical pyschiatry. When I went into practice I always felt I had a better grasp of psychodynamics than many of my colleagues because of this disciplined, classical approach.

I would think the same would be true with bonsai. So I say go for it!

GaryS

CC,
I'd be interested in what you've heard, pro and con, about apprenticing.

My own feeling is that apprenticing of any kind is a good thing so long as the teacher knows their subject well and the apprentice is open, honest, and willing to learn. If the two are put together accelerated learning can take place. If not, it's a waste of time for both the teacher and the apprentice.

__________________
GaryS