Bonsai Today Magazine - looking for editors

FlyBri

Come on Vance! Is Will writing your material now? Anybody with a whit of Bonsai knowledge knows that the sexiest specimen - when displayed with a "scantily clad vixen" accent - is Hawthorne, with Berberis coming a close second.

Fly.

__________________
Australian Native Plants as Bonsai Study Group
ANPB Galleries
---
rrr.org.au - Support Free-Range Radio

Advertisement

Vance Wood

I was not referring to sexy I was referring to goose-ability, and if we keep this up you are going to get me into trouble. Any one who has stuck there hand into a San Jose Juniper will no doubt remember what a surprise that was the first time.

__________________
The only finished bonsai is a dead one; me 1992 MABA Des Moines Iowa

Joanie

And anyone who has been "bit" by a barberry would be pretty careful to give the tree respect.

That must have been a joke, Zen. Although it probably would increase sales, and guys wouldn't care as much about content.

Pretty funny joke, come to think of it......!

But let's hope that the new editor(s) will have knowledge of bonsai, not just editing in general. We want good stuff!!

Joanie

__________________
"You can say any foolish thing to a dog, and the dog will give you a look that says,
'Wow, you're right! I never would've thought of that!'" ~ Dave Barry

rockm

The old U.K.-based (now defunct) "Bonsai and Japanese Gardens" was owned by an HFM-wanna be publisher. There is an ad for other magazines in every issue of this mag that I have that includes a photo of a scantliy clad chick on a jet ski/motrocycle/Ferarri. Other magazines in the ad were for "extreme sports" and other "kid-stuff". Always thought it was amusing.

Attila

Nobody here should think that there is only one way of doing the above mentioned tasks. Sure, there are many ways of doing them, it could be a dozen, as you mentioned, but eventually you will cover them all, and then all you can do is to repeat the techiques in the subsequent issues of BT.

There are many people who are only concerned with techniques, and not much else. Granted, good techniques are vital to the creation of bonsai. But the problem is, there is more to art then pure techniques.

Pick up any art magazine, take painting for instance. See how many articles deal with a step-by-step technical description of how to create a world-class painting.
None.
If they started doing that, 90% of the subscibers would cancel their subscriptions. They don't care how paintings were created. They want to see the work of art, and talk about it, that's all.
Same with any other art forms. They all have very sophisticated techniques, but no magazine talks about them.

Bonsai is, of course, light years behind those art forms, but as its popularity grows, there are more and more people who want to admire its beauty and see them as works of art. And, just as with other works of art, they care less about how these trees were created, and more about their artistic value. So, a bonsai magazine needs to keep up with the times and shift its focus from technique to art, trying to find a balance between the two. You are trying to satisfy both the "art" and "technique" crowd, but you will never be able to do both at 100%. That is the dillemma.

I remember the old days when every bonsai gathering started and ended with talking about rules and techniques to the crowd. Fortunately, this is slowly changing now. There are people, like Walter Pall, who recongize that there is more to bonsai then showing how to wire and re-pot. They actually want the audience to have some fun! What a blasphemy!

There are always the nerds who thrive on the technical side and sit the whole thing out from the beginning to the end.
Then there is the other half of the crowd who after an hour of watching a guy wire and clip, they start yawning and they leave. They don't care.
This is the mixed crowd you have to please as a magazine. You want to please the techno-nerds but you also want rest of the crowd to have some fun.

And guess what: the crowd who get bored to death and leave, those are the ones with the big money. They would be the "collectors", the "patrons", the ones paying the bill, if only we wouldn't chase them away with the boring details.

The ones who only care about the techniques, are of course the cheapskates. They want to create bonsai from scratch, and never pay more than a few hundred dollars for a tree. If the bonsai business relies on their money exclusively, it will be barely enough to get by.

P.S.: Anyone who REALLY want to learn techniques, should get a teacher or take workshops. It's not a magazine's job to do that. A magazine can only get you a taste of that.

TreeBay

Vance, I believe the subject of this thread is actually a contest.


Regards,



Matt

__________________

Want to be a seller on bonsaiAUCTIONS? Get authorized today!

bonsaiTALK: Over 100,005.36 Megabytes Served this Month!

Attila

Matt, that has changed a long time ago. It became "deconstructing BT", which BTW is not necessarily a bad thing in my opinion. It actually provides priceless info to some people.

Vance Wood

I can't understand why you are bringing this up now, my remark which you posted above was post #3 on the first page of this thread. If anyone is now bringing up the subject of Will Heath it is you. But I will make sure I don't mention Will Heath again in this thread.

__________________
The only finished bonsai is a dead one; me 1992 MABA Des Moines Iowa

RonMartin(deceased)

Actually it seems more like an add for BT.