View Single Post
Old 22-May-2005   #6
Candy_J_Shirey
bonsaiTALK Master Craftsman
Candy_J_Shirey's a bonsaiTALK supporter! Click Here to find out how you can be one too!
 
Candy_J_Shirey's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun-2003
Location: New Hampshire, USA
Country: United States
Posts: 526
Send a message via AIM to Candy_J_Shirey Send a message via MSN to Candy_J_Shirey Click Here to Skype Candy_J_Shirey
Quote:
Originally Posted by Elm237
But sugar maples will work right?


Elm237 -

It is my opinion that sugar maples will not easily make believable bonsai.

You may get three sugar maple seedlings planted on a rock but it would be most difficult to get it to qualify as a specimen bonsai. As stated, the leaves are difficult to reduce. Ramification will be difficult because of the long internodes.

Now, is it worth trying even if it will never be a specimen bonsai? Perhaps the trees will still have a lesson for you (as far as the care, patience, soil. water etc.) and the lesson will be in the development of the bonsai caretaker and not the specimen bonsai.

My hope for you would be to spend your time on more worthy material and feel the excitement and satisfaction of success before attempting difficult/impossible material. In this sceniaro, both the development of the bonsai caretaker and the specimen bonsai may progress.

The best to your future and your future trees.

-Candy
Candy_J_Shirey is offline   Reply With Quote