Originally Posted by designguy

Smoke-

Can bonsai be considered art if its creation is merely the repetition of the same or similar images (versions) of a tree in a pot? Fundamentally we are trying to re-create an image (tree in pot) that was mastered along time ago. If other art movements remained this stagnant creating the same basic image over and over again they probably would not be considered art. Generally artists have been inspired to create new and original works by the art that had proceeded them. Sometimes drastically changing the course and direction, we perceived art as being. I think any true art form should be in a state of constant flux. Changing and moving in different directions through varying styles and imagery. Influenced by a range of external factors whether they be social, ethnic, personal or collaborative etc.. I'm not certain that this is happening in bonsai. I think you are trying to elevate the technical proficiency or skill of the general practitioner through your comments on this forum and not a level of artistry.

Thanks
Mark-