Quote:
|
Originally Posted by RonMartin
The triangle implies:
1. Stability - The triangle is a shape with a wide base and therefore can not be easily knocked over (blown over?). The relativity of this to bonsai should be obvious, age=stability.
2. Scalene - symmetry is also a sign of stability but it does not include a lot of variety and/or interest. In bonsai terms, the symmetrical tree could become a tree by rote rather than a tree of artistic merit. Scalene is NOT symmetrical so avoids that problem but therefore needs stability of the triangle. Therefore a scalene (non-symmetrical) triangle.
3. Implied - By creating a bonsai with just the limits or corners of a scalene triangle evident, the artist requires the viewer to become a participant in the artistic work therefore adding interest for the viewer.
[/size]Ron Martin
|
I don't know if I'd call this a "call to correct" or not, but one of your points above got me thinking. You state that a triangle has a wide base. That isn't necessarily the case. Not something I'd really press to change in your article, but, noting that, have you ever seen a bonsai that has its narrowest edge of the scalene along the bottom? One that works at least? I'm about to go looking for one/any and see how it works.
A narrow-based triangle would imply a tall tree, seen in the distance. I'm most likely to find it as a formal upright, but we'll see.
Comments?