bonsaiTALK Community - View Single Post

Quote:

Originally Posted by FredL

OK, Ron, let's not break it down. Perhaps you could tell me then, is one of your 5s good news or bad news if I send in one of my pictures? Is one of your 5s better or worse than one of my 7s? What is the lowest score you'd give any of the current thumbnails? The highest? What is the average score you give? Well, for that matter, have you taken the time to give any feedback at all?

Or is all this confidential and I don't have a need to know?

Fred

Why are you so ready to jump. Calm down.
As to your questions Yes I have given some feed back. In this area not only is your assertion wrong but totally uncalled for.
Consider the ratings akin to the peoples choice award at a convention. Those that give feed back do so with their own eye. That rating is based on what the viewer thinks of the tree.
If we divided the trees as to the experience of the person that did it then we would also have to divide those that give the feed back by their experience level. Not really a smart thing to do. Way too complicated.
Not needed and probably not possible.
The system as it is now seems to be liked by those that use it. No reason to mess that up.
But if it will make you happy I promise never to give feed back on any of your thumbnails. I am not out to get you so just put your guns back in their holster.
Run off and give me a bad remark on my Reputation thing but let me have and express an opinion without worrying about you having a heart attack.