mkonig

Hi Tony
well said!
I have spend many years learning the priciples behind classical bonsai design and "copied" the styles of trees that are created using these rules.
But....there comes a time when you start to put your own observations and your own creative elements in to your designs. Naturalistic does not mean that basic principles are ignored, just used in different ways.
Trees evolve! Most of us do not start with mature specimens and whatever school of thought you follow, you have to work with the material you've got. As our trees mature they will change their image many times (as trees do in nature). Many "faults" such as crossing branches on mature trees are eliminated, not as a design option, but from horticultural necessity.

Having said that, I don't think the discussion about which style of bonsai to follow will ever be resolved and for me thats a good thing. If no one questions, we would all be like sheep and follow the one in front.
Challenge of thought is good for development, challenge of design provokes thought. Keep questioning and the future will be bright and diverse.

Mike

__________________
I refuse to have a battle of wits with an unarmed person