FredL

Sauvagii, first, let me qualify my comments. I have only 2 years of recent experience and am working to get my trees ready for initial styling. With that in mind, I will tell you what I think.

First, this is a very interesting tree and in experienced hands could probably become a pretty good tree in time. It is some sort of Elm, probably Chinese and is off to a decent start.

However, it is not much of a bonsai at this point. It is decent Bonsai MATERIAL, but, not yet a bonsai. In fact, I think it fair to say, it has been put into a bonsai pot prematurely.

Two things need attention. More will later, but these two first. They are, the roots and nebari as well as the top of the trunk where it has been cut off flat.

The base of the tree needs to be lower and the roots given a chance to develop more evenly and with out the cut off ends showing above the surface. I think this should be done in a growbox rather than in the present (very pretty) pot.

Second, a decision needs to be made as to whether you want an informal upright or broomstyle tree. Either should work for this tree, but I'd suggest yo take a look at some pictures, then decide. Either way, the flat top must be refined in a manner appropriate to the style selected.

I hope this is helpful. You may receive advice from others, but, I'll be surprized if it is not generally along these lines. You have received a nice tree from your friend but it is probably 3 or 4 years away from being a good quality Bonsai.

Best regards, Fred