smallttruth

If you don't like the tree, you don't like it, but don't believe that it is certainly the case that this tree will always be what it is. Especially with species like Chinese Elm, it is often the case that they can undergo dramatic change in relatively short amounts of time. I think you have a decent shot at making this tree look much more mature and 'bonsai' if you plant it over a tile for awhile, after reducing the root structure, and tying a cable just over the top of the current surface. A little time deeper in the ground, and a nice trunk chop may, within a few growing seasons, change your mind about this tree's potential, and if not, you could always sell it later as a 'project'. No need to be dishonest. There are plenty of people interested in taking on a challenge. I personally think its a lot of fun. Besides, some of the trends today in bonsai are not, in my view, a good measurement of whether a tree has potential. For instance, the premise that thickness and taper are good, has led to the conclusion that ridiculously disproportionate thickness and taper must be better. This seems to me a mistake. I have seen some pretty ridiculous looking 'specimens' out there, that no longer resemble any mature tree I have ever seen. It has become a competition to stretch the bounds of possibility, which mat be interesting, but does not necessarily produce nice looking trees. Also, changing the subject, I would recommend against using so much organic material. A good inorganic soil, like turface, lava rock, and pumice will help your roots avoid wet feet and increase the air in the soil. It will also reduce your chances of disease and infestation. You will have to water and fertilize a bit more, but it is well worth it. Since switching to near or entirely inorganic soils I have found that my trees have become much healthier and their roots are thriving. At any rate, enjoy your work and good luck with the tree, whatever you do with it.