Quote:
Originally posted by bonsaial1
I feel the future look of this tree has been enriched by the thought provoking critique of someone else, and the desire to improve it meant that I was willing to take a chance on the thoughts of someone else.
Bonsai-al
|
I can certainly see your point Al - but I think that this experience can be gained without "showing" your tree. I have the good fortune to be able to participate in a number of workshops which are available (if I drive for one or two hours each way) on a monthly basis from various Bonsai "masters" in the area. I, personally, see this as a much better use of the time spent - even with travel time.
I recognize that the need to do a Show is very much a part of the Bonsai community that exists today. The show is mainly a "display" that is attended by members from other clubs as well as the general public. It is my observation that attendance is dwindling. It seems to me there should be more to be gained than just overhearing some comments that might prove useful from the very few people who attend... I appreciate that the information that you received was very valuable - you got it from someone (THE JUDGE) whose judgement you valued - NOT the attendees of the Show.
Just out of curiousity - did YOU learn from the Pre-Show critique done by the other club members? Are they really honest? It seems like this could get a bit tense!