Zuishi

I think that an important consideration in this discussion is the difference between an "art" and "the art." The miniaturization of trees in pots can be an "art." When we are being more spacific we usually call this "the art" of Bonsai. Far from petty manipulation of language, this charachterizes a critical difference. I submit that I could paint a beautifull perspective of an elegently dressed couple going to a ball. (Please assume this is quality with no question as to its artistic merit.) Now, I try to suggest that my picture is Preraphealite. Or likewise, I make a beautifull unfired pot and call it art. Now I try to call it Raku. Niether of these would fly, and for good reason. Both are art, but neither fit the established bounderies of "the art" they claim to be. Raku is, by definition, fired, and preraphealites used only techniques created before the renaissance; hence no perpectives.

D.S.

edited for atrocious spelling and grammer (apologies)