agraham

I have a feeling that those who strive for excellence and who are "self motivated" will achieve excellence whether taught with kid gloves or harsh criticism.Fragile egos need not apply.

And then there are those that may have the talent and capabilities to achieve excellence and yet are timid in their approach because of early criticism.

And of course,there are those who demand excellence from others even if their own efforts are lacking any kind of originality and artistry....and while I do have some people in mind with this statement,I am not speaking of anyone in particular.There are plenty of experts on the forums who know all the rules and have plenty of experience but who create less than exciting art.

Not being in the education field I don't know all the theories of teaching.But,as a superviser of a large number of people,all with differing personalities and capabilities,I realize that different people respond to different methods for maximizing their performance.

Speaking to Al directly....I admire and appreciate your work and the efforts you have put forth in educating on the forums.There are some who take disagreement as disrespect.I don't think you fall in this category,at least I hope not.All the knowledge and thought provoking posts you provide are too valuable to us to lose.Even if,some of the provoked thought is not in agreement with your own philosophy. I don't think I have seen anyone actively promote mediocrity.Some,myself included,have learned that mediocrity is the best some can or are willing to do.We don't all have the same passion,drive and/or abilities.Why bash someone for partaking in an activity they love even when their results are less than good?

andy

__________________
http://pittmandavis.com/