|
Old Mister Crow
Join Date: May-2002
Location: Seattle, WA.
Country: USA
Posts: 3,197
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Wen
There are undoubtedly readers of the Journal of the American Bonsai Society who do not frequent this or other sites, who are unaware of the mistake and apology.
...
It is true the bonsai periodicals most of us read are not peer-reviewed scientific journals. However, I expect the editors of bonsai magazines and journals should still be concerned with the integrity of all material in their publications. I would hope this concern remains no matter how unintentional or accidental the mistake, and regardless of the author's credentials, prior achievements, or enthusiasm.
|
I agree. There's nothing wrong with aiming for the highest standards of professionalism; this would suggest that any bonsai publication, be it print or online, should print a correction / acknowledgment of any erroneous, plagarized, or otherwise problematic article published there.
Best regards,
Carl
|